For Sale By Owner Signs: Do They Help or Harm a Sale?

If you’re planning to sell your home on your own, chances are you’ve considered putting up a “for sale by owner” sign in the yard. It feels like a natural step. But before you plant that sign in the ground, it’s worth asking: Do for sale by owner signs help a FSBO home sale, or could they cause more harm than good?

In this brief guide, we’ll examine how for sale by owner signs might influence buyer assumptions and the challenges they can cause sellers.

While selling on your own might save on commission fees, it also comes with unique challenges, some of which start with that simple sign in the yard.

Sell Without a Realtor: Get an All-Cash Offer

Avoid agent commissions by selling through HomeLight’s Simple Sale platform. Skip repairs and showings and receive an all-cash offer in 24 hours (close in as little as 10 days). You can also see an estimate of how much you might get selling with a top-rated agent. It might surprise you.

Request Offer

Do for sale by owner signs help or hurt a sale?

A FSBO sign can be a double-edged sword. On one hand, it offers visibility. Passersby and neighbors will know your home is on the market, and local buyers might take notice. On the other hand, that same sign can signal to buyers that you’re selling without an agent, which can trigger concerns about pricing, negotiations, and the overall process.

The reality is, for sale by owner signs come with tainted perceptions. Yes, some buyers might be open to working directly with a homeowner if the price is right. However, FSBO statistics indicate that most buyers feel more comfortable going through a professional agent.

We’ll look at the data in a minute, but first, let’s examine common assumptions buyers make when they see a FSBO sign and why these perceptions matter.

Common buyer perceptions of FSBO signs

When potential buyers see a for sale by owner sign, they can make snap judgments, often erring on the side of caution. This is because, for most people, buying a home is the largest financial transaction of their lives. They’re hesitant to trust someone they likely perceive as an amateur or a deal with no established safeguards.

Here are some of the common concerns that FSBO signs can trigger:

• Working with an inexperienced seller: Buyers may assume the seller isn’t familiar with the process, which can make the transaction feel riskier or more complicated.
• Paperwork and process fears: Without an agent involved, buyers may worry they’ll be left to figure out contracts, inspections, and other steps on their own.
• Cheapskate or cut corners fears: Seeing a FSBO sign might lead buyers to assume the seller is trying to save money at all costs, even if it means cutting corners.
• Fair price fears: Buyers could suspect the home is overpriced or that the seller won’t budge during negotiations.
• Property condition fears: There’s often a concern that the seller is offloading a problem property without disclosing all the details.
• Transparency fears: Without an agent to mediate, buyers may feel the seller won’t be fully honest about the home’s condition, liens, zoning issues, or history.
• A fear that the listing is not legitimate: Some buyers might question whether the sale is part of a scam or a property caught up in a family dispute, especially without the credibility of a formal listing.
• Discrimination fears: Buyers may worry that a private seller won’t follow fair housing laws, which protect against discrimination based on race, color, sex (including sexual orientation and gender identity), national origin, religion, disability, or familial status.

These concerns don’t always surface, but when they do — whether consciously or unconsciously — they can limit your pool of interested buyers or complicate negotiations.

As a seller aware of these potentially harmful assumptions, you can take proactive steps to temper their impact through positive communication and marketing. However, there are two sides to a FSBO sign — one that influences buyer perceptions and one that can take a toll on your time and efforts as a seller.

Learn more: Pros and Cons of “For Sale By Owner” (FSBO) Home Sales

Challenges sellers face when using FSBO signs

For sale by owner signs often bring challenges that catch FSBO sellers off guard. Without an agent to filter inquiries or manage the process, you can face added stress and safety risks. Here are some common issues to expect so you are better prepared:

• You may attract unqualified buyers: Without a screening process, anyone can inquire about your home, whether they’re financially prepared or not.
• People may come unannounced, asking for a showing: A sign in the yard invites drop-ins. You might find strangers at your door requesting a tour with little to no notice.
• Curious non-buyers may waste your time: Some inquiries come from neighbors, looky-loos, or others who aren’t serious about buying but want to see the inside of your home.
• Some buyer’s agents ignore FSBO properties: Agents may avoid showing FSBO homes to their clients, either because they prefer working with another professional, fear complications in the transaction, or their clients need a seller who is willing to pay the buyer’s agent’s Realtor fees.
• Expect an onslaught of calls from agents: Your sign might attract more attention from local real estate agents hoping to list your home than from potential buyers themselves.
• You take on full responsibility for showings and safety: Hosting showings without an agent means managing safety concerns on your own. You’ll need to vet potential buyers and monitor the showing process.
• Negotiations can become more personal and difficult: Without an agent to act as a buffer, discussions about price, repairs, or closing terms can get tense or uncomfortable.

These hurdles don’t necessarily mean a FSBO sign isn’t worth it, but they’re important to prepare for if you decide to handle all the showings and sale process by yourself.

Learn more: How to Sell a House By Owner (A Seller’s FSBO Guide)

Why FSBO signs are rare today (the stats)

In today’s real estate landscape, the yard sign isn’t the powerhouse marketing tool it once was. Gone are the days when buyers cruised neighborhoods looking for homes. Now, all buyers search online, browsing listings from the comfort of their couch.

According to the National Association of Realtors’ latest Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers report:

• 100% of buyers use the internet at some point during their home search.
• 64% of buyers start their home search online or by contacting an agent, not by driving around looking for signs.
• 86% of buyers purchase their home through a real estate agent, showing how critical professional guidance remains.
• 90% of sellers work with an agent, leaving only a small slice of the market selling independently.
• Only 6% of homes are sold by owner, marking a historical low. And nearly 40% of FSBO sellers already know their buyer, often a friend, relative, or neighbor.

But perhaps the biggest reason FSBO signs are rare: Owner-sold homes generally sell for less money. The median sale price for FSBO homes is $380,000, while the median for all home sales is $435,000. That’s a $55,000 difference that can’t be overlooked.

Learn more: How Much Less Do FSBO Homes Sell For?