Chicago vs Detroit: Which City is Right for You? Comparing Real Estate, Cost of Living, Culture, and More

You might be weighing an apartment in downtown Chicago or a historic home in Detroit, as both cities offer rich histories and evolving urban landscapes. Chicago is known for its skyline, diverse economy, and iconic cultural scene, while Detroit is gaining momentum with its affordability and revitalized neighborhoods. Whether you’re drawn to Chicago’s busy streets or Detroit’s comeback story, choosing your next home is a significant decision.

From real estate costs and employment prospects to living expenses and community vibes, there are many factors to consider. In this Redfin article, we’ll explore the differences to help you determine which city is the right fit for your next home purchase.

Housing in Chicago vs Detroit

Chicago and Detroit present two distinct real estate landscapes, with Chicago offering a blend of urban condos and suburban homes, while Detroit’s revitalized neighborhoods bring affordable options to the table. 

Housing in Chicago

Chicago’s housing market offers a balance between urban high-rises and spacious suburban homes. Buyers can choose from sleek condos in the heart of the city or homes in areas like Hyde Park or Lincoln Park. Chicago’s housing offers more space compared to NYC, with a variety of options to fit different lifestyles.

Median home cost: The median home sale price in Chicago is around $360,000, offering more affordable housing compared to major metropolitan areas, especially in neighborhoods just outside of downtown.
Average rental cost: Renting an apartment in Chicago averages around $2,202 per month, making it a more affordable option compared to many other large cities, with prime locations like River North and the Loop attracting higher rates.

Housing in Detroit

Detroit’s real estate market is known for its affordability and growing investment potential. Buyers will find a wide selection of historic homes in areas like Boston-Edison or modern developments in the downtown area. Detroit’s ongoing revitalization efforts have created a unique blend of historic charm and new housing opportunities.

Median home cost: The median home sale price in Detroit is around $91,500, making it one of the most affordable cities in the U.S., with significant potential for growth.
Average rental cost: The average rent in Detroit is approximately $1,680 per month, providing highly affordable living options compared to other major cities.

Cost of living in Chicago vs Detroit

Chicago’s overall cost of living is about 10% higher than Detroit’s, driven mainly by differences in housing, utilities, and lifestyle expenses. Let’s break down the key areas that contribute to these differences:

1. Utilities:

While Chicago’s utilities are approximately 3% lower than Detroit’s, the city’s colder winters result in higher heating costs. On the flip side, Detroit benefits from slightly lower utility rates, especially for electricity and water.

2. Groceries:

Groceries in Chicago cost about 1% more than in Detroit. Chicago’s larger population and demand for a wider variety of products drive up prices. In contrast, Detroit’s proximity to local agriculture and lower overall cost of living helps keep grocery prices down.

3. Transportation:

Chicago’s transportation costs are 4% higher than Detroit’s. Although Chicago has a more extensive public transportation network, it also comes with higher fares. Detroit’s car-centric infrastructure is generally more affordable, though parking and driving in Chicago can significantly increase transportation expenses.

4. Healthcare:

Healthcare costs are about the same in both cities. While Chicago boasts more specialized medical facilities, its healthcare costs are balanced out by Detroit’s more affordable options.

5. Lifestyle:

Surprisingly, lifestyle expenses in Chicago are 5% lower than in Detroit. While Chicago offers a rich arts and entertainment scene, it tends to be pricier. Detroit, though still developing, provides more affordable cultural and lifestyle experiences.

Chicago vs Detroit in size and population

Chicago and Detroit, two iconic Midwestern cities, differ significantly in size and population. Chicago spans 227 square miles with a population of 2.7 million, making it one of the largest and densest cities in the U.S. Its urban core and expansive suburbs provide a mix of city life and quieter residential areas. Detroit, while smaller at 142 square miles and home to roughly 639,000 residents, is in the midst of a revitalization. Detroit’s population density is much lower, and its neighborhoods are more spread out, but the city is gaining momentum with new development and cultural growth, offering more space and affordability compared to Chicago’s busier urban atmosphere.

Weather and climate in Chicago vs Detroit

Both Chicago’s climate and Detroit’s climate experience all four seasons, but Chicago’s winters are harsher due to its location near Lake Michigan, which intensifies the cold and brings heavy snowfall. The “lake effect” creates biting winds and significant snow accumulation, making winter conditions more extreme compared to Detroit. Detroit, though still cold and snowy, generally experiences less severe winter weather. Summers in both cities are warm and humid, with Chicago benefiting from breezy conditions due to its lakeside location. Both cities face occasional thunderstorms, with Detroit also prone to tornadoes, while Chicago’s weather is more influenced by lake-driven patterns.

The job market in Chicago vs Detroit

Chicago: A diverse economy led by finance, manufacturing, and healthcare

Chicago’s job market thrives on its diverse mix of finance, manufacturing, and healthcare industries, cementing its status as an economic powerhouse in the Midwest. The city has an employment rate of 64% and a median household income of $74,000. With an average hourly wage of $33.41, Chicago offers competitive earnings, especially considering its lower cost of living compared to NYC. The finance industry, led by the Chicago Board of Trade, and a growing tech sector, alongside healthcare institutions like Northwestern Memorial Hospital, provide ample job opportunities. Chicago’s broad economic base makes it a stable and attractive city for professionals across a wide range of industries.

Detroit: Revitalized manufacturing and emerging tech

Detroit’s job market, historically known for its auto industry, is experiencing a resurgence, driven by revitalized manufacturing and an emerging tech scene. The city’s employment rate is around 49%, with a median household income of $38,000. The average hourly wage is $30.94, reflecting Detroit’s more affordable cost of living. Major employers like General Motors and Ford continue to dominate the manufacturing sector, while new tech startups are making their mark in the city’s growing innovation ecosystem. Healthcare also plays a significant role, with institutions like Henry Ford Health System providing steady employment. Detroit’s ongoing recovery makes it an evolving market with growing opportunities for job seekers.

Transportation in Chicago vs Detroit

Chicago: Extensive public transit and car-friendly

Chicago offers an extensive public transportation system, with the CTA’s “L” trains and bus routes providing easy access across the city. Many residents rely on public transit, particularly in the downtown area, which is highly walkable. The Divvy bike-share program has also made biking more accessible. While public transit is widely used, driving is more feasible in Chicago than in cities like NYC, with more available parking and wider streets, making car ownership a practical option for many residents.

Walk Score: 77
Bike Score: 72
Transit Score: 65

Detroit: Car-centric with limited transit

Detroit remains a car-centric city, with most residents depending on personal vehicles for commuting. Public transportation options, while available, are more limited compared to cities like Chicago. The Detroit Department of Transportation (DDOT) offers bus services, but the city lacks an extensive rail network. As the city continues to revitalize, walkability is improving in some neighborhoods, and the MoGo bike-share program is gaining popularity. However, driving remains the primary mode of transportation for most Detroiters.

Walk Score: 51
Bike Score: 52
Transit Score: 36

Lifestyle and things to do in Chicago and Detroit

A day in the life of a Chicagoan

Living in Chicago offers a blend of bustling urban life and midwestern charm, with each neighborhood contributing its own distinct feel. Mornings might begin with a stroll through one of the many local coffee shops in Lincoln Park or Wicker Park before heading to work in the Loop. Weekends in Chicago are filled with outdoor activities along Lake Michigan, exploring cultural festivals, or catching a game at Wrigley Field. The city’s rich architectural history, renowned museums, and vibrant theater scene keep residents constantly engaged. For music lovers, the city’s deep jazz and blues roots offer plenty of live performances, while foodies can indulge in everything from deep-dish pizza to upscale dining.

Top things to do in Chicago:

Visit the Art Institute of Chicago
Watch a comedy show at The Second City
Take an architecture boat tour along the Chicago River
Explore the Field Museum
Enjoy live jazz at The Green Mill

Google Street View of the Field Museum

Chicago parks and outdoor activities:

Walk or bike along the Lakefront Trail
Kayak on the Chicago River
Attend outdoor concerts in Millennium Park
Picnic at Grant Park
Explore the Lincoln Park Conservatory

Google Street View of Grant Park

Chicago tourist attractions:

Willis Tower Skydeck
Navy Pier
Millennium Park
Lincoln Park Zoo
Chicago Riverwalk

A day in the life of a Detroiter

Living in Detroit offers a mix of historic charm and a spirit of revitalization. Mornings might start with coffee at a local café in Midtown or Corktown before heading downtown to work. Detroit’s automotive history is ever-present, but the city is evolving with a growing arts scene and new industries. Weekends often include visiting Eastern Market, catching a Tigers game, or exploring Detroit’s art museums. The city’s revitalized waterfront and green spaces provide ample opportunities for outdoor activities, while music lovers can dive into Detroit’s legendary Motown and techno music heritage.

Top things to do in Detroit:

Explore the Detroit Institute of Arts
Visit the Motown Museum
Attend a concert at the Fox Theatre
Take a walking tour of Detroit’s historic architecture
Stroll through Eastern Market

Google Street View of Detroit Institute of Arts

Detroit parks and outdoor activities:

Bike along the Detroit Riverwalk
Kayak on the Detroit River
Picnic at Belle Isle Park
Walk through the Dequindre Cut Greenway
Explore the outdoor exhibits at the Michigan Science Center

Google Street View of Belle Isle Park

Detroit tourist attractions:

The Henry Ford Museum
Belle Isle Aquarium
Detroit Historical Museum
Campus Martius Park
Detroit Opera House

Food and culture in Chicago vs Detroit

Chicago: The Windy City

Chicago, known as “The Windy City,” is a food lover’s paradise with its hearty and diverse culinary scene. While iconic deep-dish pizza, Chicago-style hot dogs, and Italian beef sandwiches are what most people think of, the city’s food offerings are far more expansive. From upscale dining experiences in the West Loop to Mexican cuisine in Pilsen, every neighborhood brings a unique flavor to the table. Chicago’s cultural landscape is just as rich, with major festivals like the Taste of Chicago and the Chicago Blues Festival attracting crowds for food, music, and entertainment. The city is also a beacon for arts and live performances, with its renowned theaters and jazz clubs offering a cultural experience that rivals any major city.

Detroit: The Motor City

Detroit’s culinary scene is gaining momentum as the city undergoes a cultural revival. Known for its Coney dogs, Detroit-style pizza, and soul food, the city’s rich food traditions are rooted in its history but continue to evolve with the influx of new restaurants and chefs. Eastern Market, one of the largest public markets in the U.S., offers a taste of the city’s farm-to-table culture, while innovative eateries are popping up in Midtown and Corktown. Detroit’s culture extends beyond food, with a strong focus on music, particularly Motown and techno, which were born in the city. With growing arts districts, the Detroit Institute of Arts, and historic music venues, Detroit is a city that offers a deep and evolving cultural experience.

Chicago vs Detroit sports scene

Chicago: Basketball and baseball passion

Chicago’s sports culture runs deep, with a focus on basketball and baseball. The Bulls and Cubs are cornerstone teams that ignite the city’s enthusiasm, and their iconic venues, the United Center and Wrigley Field, are packed with devoted fans during game days. Football also plays a major role in Chicago’s sports identity, as the Bears unite the city each season at Soldier Field. Hockey has a strong presence as well, with the Blackhawks boasting a storied history and passionate following.

Detroit: Auto city sports and rebuilding spirit

Detroit’s sports scene reflects the city’s resilience and rich history, with teams that have been part of the city’s identity for decades. The Detroit Lions in football and the Red Wings in hockey are among the city’s most beloved teams, with Ford Field and Little Caesars Arena providing a home for loyal fans. The Tigers and Pistons are also integral to the local sports culture, with Comerica Park drawing baseball fans downtown. While Detroit’s teams have experienced ups and downs, the city’s fanbase remains dedicated, embodying the spirit of a city constantly rebuilding and evolving.

The post Chicago vs Detroit: Which City is Right for You? Comparing Real Estate, Cost of Living, Culture, and More appeared first on Redfin | Real Estate Tips for Home Buying, Selling & More.